SIA ANTITRUST POLICY STATEMENT
The Security Industry Association (SIA) is an association of suppliers, many of which compete with each other. As an association of competitors in the security products industry, SIA must act cautiously to ensure against violations of federal and state antitrust laws.
Topics which should not be discussed during association meetings include those that could be construed as an agreement even tending to (a) raise, lower or stabilize prices or price levels, including credit terms, (b) regulate production or the availability of products or services, (c) allocate markets or customers, or (d) encourage boycotts or dealing only on certain terms.
Even if you are not an active participant in a discussion which could violate the antitrust laws - that is, if you are merely present while others engage in such a discussion and you neither attempt to stop it nor leave the room - you personally could be convicted of a felony and fined as much as $350,000 and/or imprisoned for up to three years. If your company or SIA is convicted, each could be fined up to $10 million.
First, an agreement does not need to be in writing to be illegal under the antitrust laws. Agreements can be oral or written, formal or informal, express or implied. In fact, agreements can be inferred from similar behavior following even a general discussion of a particular matter such as prices or output. For this reason, mere discussion of certain topics must not be permitted at SIA meetings. Should an improper discussion be initiated, it is staff's responsibility to advise that it be terminated and to move on to another, appropriate topic. Should those present not heed staff's advice, it is the responsibility of staff to terminate the meeting and recommend that all persons leave.
Price fixing is an agreement among competitors which tends to standardize (to raise, maintain or even to lower) prices or price levels. Agreements which go even to individual elements of price such as discounts, credit terms, warranties or profit margins are violations of the antitrust laws and are not permitted.
Agreements to limit production are viewed as the equivalent of price fixing because the end result is the same. Since price is a result of supply and demand, agreements to limit production (to restrict supply) result in price increases if demand remains constant.
Agreements to divide customers or market areas also eliminate price competition. For example, discussion among manufacturers of who will serve a particular geographic market, or of who will sell to a particular dealer or group of dealers, or of who will advertise in the newspaper serving the north side of town and who will advertise in the newspaper serving the south side of town, is inappropriate at an SIA meeting.
Boycotts involve agreements among manufacturers not to sell to a particular dealer or group of dealers, or to sell only on certain terms.
Association statistical reporting programs are ripe with the potential for antitrust violations unless properly structured and operated. General guidelines include the following:
- Participation in the program should be absolutely voluntary.
- Non-members should be permitted to participate in the program. Non-members' participation need not be solicited, but, if a non-member asks to participate, that request should not be denied without first consulting with legal counsel. All participants, members and non- members alike, should have access to the aggregate data prepared by the independent accounting firm. Participating non-members may be charged a higher fee for the final report than participating members. The final report should also be available to distributors and dealers desiring it.
- The purpose of the program (for example, “to foster competition by providing members of the industry with historical market information for their individual use”) should be set forth in the minutes of the Board of Directors meeting authorizing the program.
- Individual company data should not be revealed or discernible from the final report. It is generally accepted that at least three companies should be reporting in any product/price range in order to avoid disclosure of individual company data.
- Most importantly, there should be no discussion of the information in the report either in writing or in association meetings. The information is generated solely for the individual use of those participating.
To summarize, when attending an association meeting, your personal red flag should go up when any of the following is mentioned or the conversation seems to be headed in that direction:
- Current or future prices. Great care should also be taken in discussing past prices. Rarely are such discussions appropriate.
What constitutes a “fair” profit level.
Possible increases or decreases in prices.
Standardization or stabilization of prices, price levels, or price points, including elimination of products in any price range.
Pricing procedures. While a discussion of cost accounting methods is appropriate, discussion of pricing formulas is potentially inappropriate.
Cash discounts. Warranty terms.
Manufacturer return policies.
Credit terms or rejection of customers.
Individual company market share, sales or production information.
Production limits or quotas.
Allocation of markets or customers.
Refusal to deal with a customer or to deal only on certain terms.
Whether or not the pricing practices of any industry member are unethical or otherwise inappropriate.
If any of these subjects are raised and SIA staff does not terminate the discussion, SIA members should first ask that the matter not be further discussed and, failing that, should leave the room.
Finally, it is important for all to understand that antitrust liability may arise other than at an SIA meeting. It is equally unlawful, for example, for two competitors to talk about pricing trends over the telephone, completely independent of an SIA event.
- SIA Antitrust Policy Statement
Community Rules & Etiquette and Privacy Guidelines
Thank you for being part of our community. To ensure the best possible experience for all members, we have established some basic guidelines for participation.
By joining and using this community, you agree that you have read and will follow these rules and guidelines. You also agree to reserve discussions and shared files and content to that best suited to the medium. This is a great medium with which to solicit the advice of your peers, benefit from their experience, and participate in an ongoing conversation. Questions should be directed to our Member Services department via the Contact Us link on this site. Technical questions on association management issues should directed to our helpdesk.
Please take a moment to acquaint yourself with these important guidelines. If you have questions, contact the member services department. In order to preserve a climate that encourages both civil and fruitful dialogue, we reserve the right to suspend or terminate membership in this community for anyone who violate these rules.
- Don't challenge or attack others. The discussions and comments are meant to stimulate conversation not to create contention. Let others have their say, just as you may.
- Don't post commercial messages on any discussion list, resource library entry, or other area where others might see it. Contact people directly with product and service information if you believe it would help them.
- Use caution when discussing products. Information posted on the lists and in the libraries is available for all to see, and comments are subject to libel, slander, and antitrust laws.
- All defamatory, abusive, profane, threatening, offensive, or illegal materials are strictly prohibited. Do not post anything that you would not want the world to see or that you would not want anyone to know came from you.
- Please note carefully all items listed in the disclaimer and legal rules below, particularly regarding the copyright ownership of information posted.
- Remember that other participants have the right to reproduce postings to this site unless you specify otherwise.
- Post your message or documents only to the most appropriate lists or libraries. Do not spam several lists or libraries with the same message.
All messages must add to the body of knowledge. We reserve the right to reject any message for any reason.
Discussion Group Etiquette
- Include a signature tag on all messages. Include your name, affiliation, location.
- State concisely and clearly the topic of your comments in the subject line. This allows members to respond more appropriately to your posting and makes it easier for members to search the archives by subject.
- Include only the relevant portions of the original message in your reply. Delete any header information, and put your response before the original posting.
- Only send a message to the entire list when it contains information that everyone can benefit from.
- Send messages such as "thanks for the information" or "me, too" to individuals--not to the entire list. Do this by using the "Reply to Sender" link to the left of every message.
- Do not send administrative messages, such as remove me from the list. Instead, use the web interface to change your settings or to remove yourself from a list. If you are changing e-mail addresses, you do not need to remove yourself from the list and rejoin under your new e-mail address. Simply change your settings.
- Warn other list subscribers of lengthy messages either in the subject line or at the beginning of the message body with a line that says "Long Message."
The Legal Stuff
This site is provided as a service for the members of SIA360. SIA360 is not responsible for the opinions and information posted on this site by others. We disclaim all warranties with regard to information posted on this site, whether posted by SIA360 or any third party; this disclaimer includes all implied warranties of merchantability and fitness. In no event shall SIA360 be liable for any special, indirect, or consequential damages or any damages whatsoever resulting from loss of use, data, or profits, arising out of or in connection with the use or performance of any information posted on this site.
Do not post any defamatory, abusive, profane, threatening, offensive, or illegal materials. Do not post any information or other material protected by copyright without the permission of the copyright owner. By posting material, the posting party warrants and represents that he or she owns the copyright with respect to such material or has received permission from the copyright owner. In addition, the posting party grants SIA360 and users of this site the nonexclusive right and license to display, copy, publish, distribute, transmit, print, and use such information or other material.
Messages should not be posted if they encourage or facilitate members to arrive at any agreement that either expressly or impliedly leads to price fixing, a boycott of another's business, or other conduct intended to illegally restrict free trade. Messages that encourage or facilitate an agreement about the following subjects are inappropriate: prices, discounts, or terms or conditions of sale; salaries; profits, profit margins, or cost data; market shares, sales territories, or markets; allocation of customers or territories; or selection, rejection, or termination of customers or suppliers.
SIA360 does not actively monitor the site for inappropriate postings and does not on its own undertake editorial control of postings. However, in the event that any inappropriate posting is brought to the attention of SIA360 we will take all appropriate action.
SIA360 reserves the right to terminate access to any user who does not abide by these guidelines.
We respect your privacy
Any personal information you provide to us including and similar to your name, address, telephone number and e-mail address will not be released, sold, or rented to any entities or individuals outside of our organization except as noted below.
With Whom Do We Share the Personal Information We Collect Through This Site
Our Service Providers.
We may share your personal information with companies (including our affiliates) that perform services on our behalf, for example, companies that help process credit card payments. Our service providers are required by contract to protect the confidentiality of the personal information we share with them and to use it only to provide specific services on our behalf.
Government and Legal Disclosures
We may disclose the personal information we collect through this Site, when we, in good faith, believe disclosure is appropriate to comply with the law (or a court order or subpoena); to prevent or investigate a possible crime, such as fraud or identity theft; to enforce our Terms and Conditions or other agreements that govern your use of this Site; or to protect the rights, property or safety of our company, our users, or others.
Remember The Risks Whenever You Use The Internet
While we do our best to protect your personal information, we cannot guarantee the security of any information that you transmit to us and you are solely responsible for maintaining the secrecy of any passwords or other account information. In addition other Internet sites or services that may be accessible through our site have separate data and privacy practices independent of us, and therefore we disclaim any responsibility or liability for their policies or actions. Please contact those vendors and others directly if you have any questions about their privacy policies.
For any other information please contact us using the Contact Us page.